About Us

In 2009, an opportunity was presented that allowed Butler Auto Recycling to create a new division specializing in used tires and auto part accessories. This division known as Butler Tire & Accessories has since added more products using this store. Each used tire we sell comes with a guarantee.

Our warehouse stores over 2,000 used tires of singles, pairs, and complete matching sets. All of the new and used tires are kept track using a computerized inventory system to help provide the most accurate quotes for our customers. We stock over 2,000 factory wheels in case you may have a damaged rim. We deal in buying and selling custom rims or upgrade factory wheels for a wide selection of vehicles.


How long have you been in business?

Butler Auto Recycling has been in business since 1977. This Pensacola used tire store started has been open since 2008.

What is your primary product or service?

We offer new and used tires, installation of 12″-22″ tires, flat repair, used batteries, reconditioned batteries, hubcaps, center caps, used custom aftermarket rims, aftermarket stereos, speakers, and other vehicle accessories.

How did you first become interested in your line of business? What is your background?

The opportunity came to purchase a building adjacent to our parts store and the storage was available to display used tires in a customer-friendly environment. Our philosophy is that anyone can sell used tires, but it takes that certain company to do it right. We may fall short sometimes, but we learn and become better than before.

How do you differentiate yourself from other businesses in your category and area?

We inventory all of our used and new tires in a computer system which provides real-time inventory to our customers. Our prices include install, balance, and tire disposal. We try to take the guessing game out of what the true price is.

How many locations do you have and do you have plans to expand?

We currently have our main tire shop, but have plans to expand in the future to help better serve the region.

Provide detailed directions to your location

We are located at 6355 North Palafox Street across from Rusty Moye auto sales. We are on Old Palafox Street in between Airport and Burgess Road. We are pretty much behind Ruby Tuesday’s that is on Pensacola BLVD, but on Old Palafox.

What type of payments do you accept?

We accept cash, check, Visa, Mastercard, American Express, Discover

Which areas do you service?

Pensacola, Cantonment, Pace, Milton, Mobile, Foley, Crestview, Fort Walton Beach, Destin

Who owns your company or runs daily operations?

Our company is owned by the family business Butler Auto Recycling

What are your hours of operation?

8:00 am – 5:00 pm – Monday-Friday
8:00 am – 4:00 pm – Saturday

What is the best compliment anyone can give you?

We make it simple and take away the up-selling that is found in the auto service industry. We warranty our products past most our competitors because we believe in our product.

What is your favorite quote or Bible verse?

If you will live like no one else, later you can live and give like no one else. – Dave Ramsey